By Ed Avis
When we started planning the 2026 Independent Mexican/Latin Restaurant of the Year Contest with our partners at Mineragua, we knew the criteria had to be broader than just making great food. After all, the best Mexican/Latin restaurants are so much more than places to grab a meal — they are community-focused places where people find comfort among neighbors and friends; connect with friendly, welcoming staff; and yes, enjoy delicious meals.
So, we decided that making great — and authentic — cuisine would be an important criterion, but that treating employees well and caring about community would carry equal weight.
Our judges — Lilly Rocha, CEO of the Latino Restaurant Association; Kathleen Furore, editor of el Restaurante; and Jazhen Gonzalez, Mineragua brand manager — struggled to choose winners from more than 200 nominations submitted from across the country. Ultimately, they chose the top three restaurants that they felt demonstrated superiority in all three areas.
We congratulate these restaurants for the outstanding way they’re serving their communities and so admirably representing the Mexican/Latin restaurant industry:
First Place: Reyes Mezcaleria, Orlando, Florida
Second Place: Casa Chaskis, Long Beach, California
Third Place: Bibisol, Sioux Falls, South Dakota
Honorable Mention:
Aldaco's Mexican Cuisine, San Antonio, Texas
Alma Cocina, Atlanta, Georgia
Castillo's Restaurant, San Jose, California
Chayo Kitchen & Tequila Bar, Las Vegas, Nevada
Taqueria La Hacienda, Chesapeake, Virginia
Xacalli, Silverado, California
Below is a profile of Reyes Mezcaleria. Watch for profiles of Casa Chaskis and Bibisol in upcoming issues of el Restaurante. Congratulations to all!
First Place: Reyes Mezcaleria
People in Orlando, Florida have plenty of decent restaurants to eat in, but since Reyes Mezcaleria opened nine years ago, they have been able to enjoy Mexican cuisine in a whole new way.
“I was born in Michoacán, Mexico, and being Mexican has shaped how I think about food and how I think about dining experiences,” says Wendy Lopez, chef/partner, who moved to Florida as a child and grew up helping out in her parents’ restaurant, La Hacienda, near St. Augustine. “My mom is an amazing cook, and each dish that she would make, she would say, ‘Oh, this your grandmother made for us when we were doing this,’ and kind of shaped the story. We’re a family full of storytellers, so it’s always fun to cook and create memories.”
Lopez formally learned cooking at Le Cordon Bleu in Orlando, and worked for Disney, Darden, and several other places before connecting with Jason and Sue Chin in 2018. The Chins, veteran restaurateurs in the Orlando area, had opened Reyes Mezcaleria the year before. Lopez became a partner and has been crafting an authentic regional Mexican dining experience ever since.
The Cuisine
The restaurant’s masa program is one example of the authenticity Lopez and her team strive for. They buy heirloom corn from Mexico through Masienda, a U.S.-based supplier of corn from small Mexican growers; have it made into masa at a local producer, Masamor Tortilla Co.; and use it to create amazing fresh tortillas and various masa-based dishes.
“The way that we introduce people to more regional food is to start with the most important ingredient in Mexico, which is corn,” Lopez says. “We can use blue, white, yellow, or red corn, all the types, depending on what we're doing with it. It’s interesting when we have masa from like, Mexico City and Oaxaca, and how you can tell the difference in the corn and the texture of the masa. Every masa, every corn has different texture and different water content that we have to adjust for. But that’s just the beauty of it for me.”
Being in Florida, fish is also important to the menu, Lopez says. They use Florida snapper to make ceviche, for example, and that’s very popular. They combine the fresh fish with the masa program in their fish tacos — the batter is made with masa to make it extra crispy.
Oaxacan enchiladas topped with house-made mole negro is another menu success.
“It takes three days to make the mole negro, and we’re super proud of it,” Lopez says. “Even just five years ago, mole wasn’t really well-received here, but by using it in something people know — enchiladas — people take a risk and really enjoy that. So that’s been very popular for us.”
The best expression of Lopez’s vision for the cuisine is Raíz, a five-course tasting menu that focuses on dishes that include heirloom corn. The November menu includes a scallop tostada made with a type of corn called conico azul; grouper cheek topped with yellow mole that includes conico amarillo corn; a tlacoyo made with olotillo blanco corn and topped with New York strip, ramps, chile guero, chivo blanco and truffled cheese; a snapper taco on a tortilla made with conico amarillo; and for dessert, a champurrado ice cream that includes conico azul and blueberries. Each course can be paired with a different agave spirit or Mexican wine.
“With Raíz, we’re really trying to build a story,” Lopez explains.
The Bar Program
Given the restaurant’s name, Reye’s Mezcaleria’s agave program also is exceptional. The inventory includes more than 150 tequilas, mezcals and other agave spirits, plus Mexican whiskey and gin.
“Half of what Jason wanted to do in the first place when they opened the restaurant was to bring more awareness to mezcal,” Lopez says. “I would say half of our collection is single bottles of different types of mezcal.”
Great Mexican restaurants don’t survive on agave cocktails alone, so the restaurant has developed a list of 10 to 12 superior Mexican wines offered by the glass so customers can take a chance on labels they are not familiar with. The sauvignon blanc and nebbiolo from Casa Jipi, a winery in Valle de Guadalupe led by famed winemaker Lulu Martínez Ojeda, are among the most popular on the list, Lopez says.
The Employees
A great restaurant does not exist without employees who are well taken care of, and that’s another area where Reyes Mezcaleria shines. The key is making employees feel valued in the workplace, explains Nicole Peters, the restaurant’s general manager.
“A lot of us kind of just fall into this industry when we’re young, and for the people who choose to make it their career and their lives, it’s important to nurture that,” Peters says. “Chef Wendy and I have made it a point of doing that through all of the years that we’ve worked together. We want to kind of rewrite the story and make people feel welcome to come talk to us to learn from us. When we were young in this industry, it was very cut throat, and it still is, but we like to lead with a little more compassion and empathy.”
Staff education plays an important role. For example, Lopez and Peters are currently teaching staff about Mexican wines so they feel confident recommending the wines and are well equipped to handle questions from customers who may be knowledgeable about fine wine but have not tried Mexican vintages.
The restaurant’s leaders also know that keeping great staff often requires creating a path to advance.
“Developing staff and moving them up within the company [is important],” Peters says. “If we have someone on staff that loves what they’re doing and is showing that they can do more and want to do more, I would rather build them up into maybe a possible career rather than looking outside of the restaurant to bring someone else in.”
The restaurant has about 45 employees, some who have been there six or seven years, says Peters, who started nine years ago.
“I started as a server and three months later I was given the opportunity to be the general manager,” she says, adding that she had restaurant management experience prior to coming to Reyes Mezcaleria. “Sue and Jason took a chance on me, and they have watched me grow up as much as I’ve watched this restaurant grow, and it’s been truly exciting and really cool. My viewpoint of hospitality has changed immensely since being here. I’ve learned that hospitality can be more than just people come in to eat and then leaving. It’s how you make people feel from the front door to how they feel the day after they dine with you.”
The Community Connection
When it comes to connecting with the community it serves, Reyes Mezcaleria excels in that category, too.
The restaurant has collaborated in recent years with Chefs for Change, The Jacques Pépin Foundation, The James Beard Foundation, The Kitchen House and World Central Kitchen.
Lopez says her work with The Kitchen House, a non-profit organization and community teaching kitchen in Orlando, stands out as one of her favorite community contributions. Through that organization, she teaches children where food comes from and how to appreciate foods they may not previously have enjoyed.
For example, after her students said they didn’t like mushrooms or tomatoes, her next class featured pasta sauce with tomatoes and mushrooms. “They said, ‘Oh, I love this!’ And I said, ‘But you said you don’t like mushrooms or tomatoes.’ So your job as the instructor is to teach them, and make it so a child can agree and can try it.”
She also has fond memories of working with is World Central Kitchen, which tapped her skills during the pandemic.
“Our staff lined up with other restaurants and hotels and we partnered up with Jaleo, Jose Andres’ restaurant here, and we made 9,000 meals,” Lopez says. “We didn't think about what we needed — we just thought about what our community needed, and our community needed food and some kind of consistency, so we did that daily for a while.”
Reyes Mezcaleria has touched the Orlando community in many ways. Its cuisine has expanded customers’ understanding of what Mexican food can be; its nurturing of employees has helped many workers grow in their careers; and its charitable efforts help feed their neighbors. It’s no surprise that the judges chose the restaurant as the 2026 Independent Mexican/Latin Restaurant of the Year.
So, what’s next for our first-place winner?
“The future for us is staying true to ourselves,” Lopez says. “Staying true to what our mantra is and continuing to highlight great small little towns, small little dishes in Mexico, and bringing light to them. And we will keep developing ourselves, developing new concepts and developing our team to continue to want to grow with us, because at the end of the day our team makes us strong. We have to make sure the people who are around us are putting in their effort and are happy to move with us.”
SIDEBAR: Thanks to our Sponsor…
There would be no Mexican/Latin Independent Restaurant of the Year Contest without the generous support from Mineragua, Mexico's iconic sparkling mineral water. Mineragua’s team shares our passion for honoring independent Mexican/Latin restaurants, and we were delighted to partner with them in this important endeavor.




